If you've ever being confused between Nigella Seeds, Black Cumin and Onion Seeds, you're not alone. The world of spices, especially in traditional Indian and Middle Eastern cooking can get a little fuzzy when it comes to names, and appearance.
Difference between Nigella Seeds and Black Cumin
Despite similar appearance, Nigella Seeds aka Kalonji is not the same as Black Cumin aka Bunium Bulbocastanum. The below table of comparison will resolve your doubts:
| Features | Nigella Sativa (Kalonji) | Black Cumin (Bunium Bulbocastanum) |
| Common names | Kalonji, Black Seeds, Nigella | Black Cumin, Shah Jeera (sometimes) |
| Flavor | Mildly bitter, Peppery | Earthy, Nutty, Sweeter than Cumin |
| Appearance | Tiny, Angular Black Seeds | Thinner, Curved Seeds, like Wild Cumin |
| Culinary Uses | Naan, Pickles, Tempering | Rice dishes, Spice Blends, Curries |
| Ayurveda Uses | Immunity, Digestion, Skin | Warming, Digestive, Gas-relieving |
Some online spicy sellers use these terms interchangeably. Hence, it might get tough for a layman to understand these effectively. But, once you know what to look for, it gets easier.
What about Onion Seeds and Nigella Sativa?
Here's the kicker. Onion Seeds aren't even used in cooking. Real Onion Seeds come from the Allium cepa plant but they are not widely available or used as a culinary spices. Nigella Seeds looks a lot like onion seeds and shares a subtle onion like flavor. Below is a simplified cheat sheet for you to understand the differences between onion seeds, nigella sativa, and black cumin by just looking at it.
| Name on Label and True Identity | Actual Spice | Flavor Notes |
| Kalonji (Correct) | Nigella Sativa | Bitter, Nutty, Peppery |
| Black Seed (Correct) | Nigella Sativa | Earthy, Oniony |
| Onion Seed (Common Mislabel) | Nigella Sativa (usually) | Slight Onion, Mild |
| Black Cumin (Often Confused) | Bunium Bulbocastanum | Sweet Cumin like |
| Shah Jeera (Not Nigella) | Carum Carvi or Bunium | Warm, Caraway-ish |
How each of these are used in Cooking?
Nigella Sativa
- Tadka for lentils and vegetables
- Sprinkled on naan or flatbreads
- Used in pickles
- Part of Bengali panch phoron
- Lightly toasted in salads or chutneys
Best for adding depth and contrast in oily or sour dishes
Black Cumin
- Used in biryani or pulao for aromatic base
- Roasted and grounded in garam masala
- Combined with regular cumin in rich gravies
Best for aroma heavy dishes where a sweet, nutty cumin tone is needed
Onion Seeds (Mislabel of Nigella)
- Used interchangeably with Nigella Sativa
- Treated in similar ways in cooking
- Found in recipes across Indian, Middle Eastern, and Turkish cuisines
When the label says "onion seed", assume it's just Nigella unless it clearly says otherwise
Why the confusion happens in differentiating between Nigella, Black Cumin, and Onion Seeds?
One of the major cause of this confusion is global trade and inconsistent labeling. A seed that's called black seed in Middle East becomes Onion Seeds in Europe and Kalonji in India, even though it's all the same thing.
To make things worse:
- Some shops mix up Shah Jeera and Kalonji, even though their flavors are entirely different.
- Many online retailers use "black cumin" as a blanket term which is not helpful.
How to avoid getting the wrong spice?
Below are the few tips that can help you to identify the correct spice you are looking for:
-
Check the botanical name
a) Nigella Sativa: Kalonji
b) Bunium Bulbocastanum: Black Cumin
c) Allium Cepa: Real Onion Seed
-
Smell it
a) Kalonji has a slight peppery, earthy scent with a hint of onion
b) Black Cumin smells warmer and sweeter like a cross between cumin and caraway
-
Check the size and shape
a) Kalonji: irregular, angular, matte black seeds
b) Black cumin: Thin, slightly curved seeds, often glossy
-
Buy from trusted sellers
a) Look for clear labeling and sourcing
b) Or skip the guesswork and get it from a place that knows the difference (like YogisGift)
At YogisGift, we offer pure Nigella Seeds (Kalonji). No confusion, no misleading labels, just fresh, sun-dried seeds ready to add depth to your meals and wellness rituals.